• 1 Post
  • 74 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: December 9th, 2023

help-circle













  • My point was not that cash wasn’t being accepted. It’s more that carrying large amounts of cash around is extremely risky for non obvious reasons.

    Not carrying a phone is definitely possible and even commendable, but for many people it’s not an option. Just off the top of my head:

    If you are in an unfamiliar area unexpectedly you won’t have been able to print off a map ahead of time

    Many people’s employers require them to be contactable during on call periods

    If you are trying to get a job/caring for a sick relative, there may be risk with being unreachable for an extended period

    Obviously these examples are things that can be worked around in many cases, but currently society is arranged around the idea that you have a phone on you if you want to do anything. I agree with you this is not a good thing, generally. If you are able to push the trend back it’s worthwhile but short of an EMP / solar flare removing all communication networks worldwide I don’t believe there is a realistic chance this changes.

    Other unsorted thoughts:

    I know bill serial numbers are tracked, if they really wanted they could probably find video of you getting money out of the bank/ATM. Again, there are workarounds but it gets to be more and more commitment to POSSIBLY be untraceable.

    If you have friends with phones who travel with you or you get photographed in the background of someone else’s social media you can get profiled that way

    • All this to say, I agree with the gist of what you are saying but I don’t think it’s realistic to expect many people to be able to do the work for something that has less tangible benefit to them than being able to pay rent. Social change will require personal habits changing along with political pressure to make databrokers illegal, prevent tracking via metadata, etc.

  • What holes do you see in the logic of this document?

    If you want to develop a solo project and also be a sex pest, no one can really stop you. If you want to be the BDFL and public face of a large organization, it’s not enough to be technically correct. You also need to be someone who is at least tolerable to interact with.





  • They grasped a small kernel of truth and encrusted a huge wad of nonsense around it. You already have to use credit for some transactions, effectively. If you try bringing 100k in cash to buy a car/house, there is a good chance it’ll get seized by police. Corporations already do that tracking and they don’t need credit card transactions for it - if you use a cell phone they know what store you went into. That can be combined with other metadata to know exactly what you’re doing. Carrying cash does not fix this.